McKinsey for Kids:
A tiger’s tale about what nature is really worth
April 29, 2021Interactive
Itching to spot a sloth or maybe track a tiger in the wild someday? In this edition of McKinsey for Kids, let’s explore mangrove forests—which have unique trees that grow near tropical-ocean coastlines—and why protecting them can help tigers and other endangered species, as well as all of us.
Spot the species
Pretend you’re exploring an imaginary wildlife sanctuary in a tropical, oceanfront mangrove forest. Here are ten animals you might see. Can you guess which ones are abundant today, which are vulnerable or endangered—as in there’s a risk there may be no more of them on Earth someday—and which are already extinct?
That was a trick question, by the way—all of these animals are vulnerable or endangered. And that means that some of the creatures you might see today could be gone tomorrow. The threats to these animals aren’t all the same, but taking the dangers they face seriously, and finding ways to protect them and the places where they live, is crucial.
Track that tiger
To understand how to save these animals, it’s important to know more about where and how they live and whether the environments they live in are at risk too. Since all of the animals we’ve talked about can be found in mangrove forests, let’s take a closer look at them.
What are mangroves? Basically, these are shrubs or small trees that you can find on coasts around the world, making up a special type of forest. These plants are unique because they can survive even in very salty water (which kills a lot of other plants), and the tropical forests they’re part of serve as a crucial link between oceans and inland communities.
Let’s trek into the mangroves.
zoom-series-1
zoom-series-2
zoom-series-3
zoom-series-4
zoom-series-5
In and around a mangrove forest
In the village. Mangrove forests protect communities. During a big tropical storm, mangroves’ tangled root systems can keep waves from destroying houses. Mangroves also naturally absorb carbon dioxide (CO₂) and purify the air people breathe.
In the forest. People may make a living off of what’s in mangrove forests. Some people harvest timber from trees that grow in the forest; others might gather honey or find materials to make traditional medicine from plants.
On the shore. Fishing, including shrimp farming and crab catching, are vital local industries. It’s important to think sustainably, so fisherfolk don’t catch more fish than can be bred for a healthy population for next year. Another way to keep fish populations healthy is by not fishing in areas where the fish lay their eggs or where they grow up.
Wading in. Many animals are found in mangroves, but the Bengal tiger is the only kind of tiger that’s evolved to live in them. Tigers play an important role as predators, keeping populations of animals like boars in check so they don’t overwhelm the forest.
Going deep. Mangroves are a breeding ground for aquatic life, with roots that shelter many young fish. Nearby seagrass and algae can feed the fish. And then it’s a quick dart to open waters when the fish are ready to swim free.
How McKinsey is helping people understand the value of nature
How does McKinsey fit into any of this? For starters, we help people understand the value of natural resources such as mangroves in a way everyone can easily understand: putting a price on what it would cost to replace such resources, for example.
So we came up with a “business case” for nature—basically, a convincing argument for why something should be done, which usually shows how it can help people save money or make more of it.
To make this business case, we built on the work of other researchers, such as the scientists that looked at how much money would be lost if we removed the mangroves.
cutaway1cutaway2cutaway3cutaway4cutaway5
A world without mangroves?
Land is sometimes measured in “hectares,” which is 10,000 square meters—roughly the size of 2.5 American football fields.
For every hectare of mangrove lost, it would cost $3,600 to build new barriers to stop coastal erosion.
The beaches would not be suitable for swimming with the increase of dangerous waves, so visitors would stop coming, and the village would lose $1,000 from tourism activities.
The missing mangrove trees’ roots and leaves would stop purifying the air and water, and it would cost $5,800 to build air-purification plants to do the same job.
Together, it would cost about $10,000 to replace the benefits of each hectare of mangrove we cut down—or $143.5 billion if you look at what would be lost if all the mangroves on Earth were wiped out. And we can’t put a dollar value on the loss of animals living in mangrove forests; they’re priceless.
People tend to forget all the benefits of nature, including mangrove forests, because they don’t cost us anything. Reminding everyone about the value of mangroves by using such big numbers is how McKinsey sometimes contributes to conversations with facts and data, so governments and other organizations can try to find ways to preserve these natural resources for animals and people.
The way we got to the math was by using maps and something called geospatial analysis. Images of the Earth’s surface, taken by satellites, showed a bird’s-eye view of mangrove forests, as well as many other types of natural areas all around the globe. For a given area, we looked at nature’s actual (sometimes shrinking) size, what species of plants and animals live there, and how close they are to (growing) human settlements. And seeing that made it easier to understand how natural areas benefit humans and wildlife and to calculate how they reduce the amount of CO₂ in our air.
This let McKinsey come up with a “before and after” picture that then allowed us to prove that conserving mangroves would have a lot of benefits without a lot of costs. And when you add it all together, we hope others will find there’s a lot to like in this math.
Many studying climate change urge global leaders to double protected natural areas by 2030.
Show potential additional conservation priorities
Existing protected areas
Potential additional conservation priorities
map base viewmap overlay view
Many scientists and conservationists studying climate change are urging global leaders to protect nature—doubling what is protected today by 2030. It could create hundreds of thousands of jobs in nature conservation too. And it could reduce the risk of another pandemic such as COVID-19 because zoonotic diseases (ones that are transmitted to humans by animals that maybe shouldn’t have been in such close proximity) tend to spread more widely when animals’ natural habitats get disrupted by human activity. It could even protect endangered species, like those ten animals we met earlier.
But what can I do?
A few places to start
click iconClick each card to learn more
Buy better
Buy better
Avoid products that are made in irresponsible ways. Too much shrimp farming can lead to mangroves being destroyed, for example, but buying shrimp or fish that is labeled as being <a href="https://fishandkids.msc.org/en/teachers/whole-school-resources/marine-sustainability">sustainably harvested</a> can help ensure that what you’re buying was produced while taking into account things like the environment.
Avoid products that are made in irresponsible ways. Too much shrimp farming can lead to mangroves being destroyed, for example, but buying shrimp or fish that is labeled as being sustainably harvested can help ensure that what you’re buying was produced while taking into account things like the environment.
Go green
Go green
Think of what you can do at home by <a href="https://www.epa.gov/watersense/watersense-kids">saving water</a>, switching off lights, and <a href="https://kids.nationalgeographic.com/nature/kids-vs-plastic">recycling or minimizing plastic waste</a>. Saving energy means there’s less CO₂ released that needs to be managed; keeping plastic and other unnatural materials out of oceans also keeps the environment safer and healthier for animals and humans alike.
Think of what you can do at home by saving water, switching off lights, and recycling or minimizing plastic waste. Saving energy means there’s less CO₂ released that needs to be managed; keeping plastic and other unnatural materials out of oceans also keeps the environment safer and healthier for animals and humans alike.
Compost
Compost
<a href="https://kids.nationalgeographic.com/books/article/create-compost">Consider composting</a> if there’s food your family can’t eat. With proper planning, food scraps can be added to soil to help your garden grow. This helps keep waste out of landfills and reduces methane emissions—important since methane, a type of gas, can contribute to climate change just as CO₂ does.
Consider composting if there’s food your family can’t eat. With proper planning, food scraps can be added to soil to help your garden grow. This helps keep waste out of landfills and reduces methane emissions—important since methane, a type of gas, can contribute to climate change just as CO₂ does.
Raise your voice
Raise your voice
Consider <a href="https://www.voicesofyouth.org/">spreading the word</a> by teaching your friends and neighbors about ways in which we can protect nature. Tell your parents, <a href="https://www.earthday.org/earth-day-2021/">celebrate Earth Day</a>, or write letters to local or national leaders who make decisions that could affect nature.
Consider spreading the word by teaching your friends and neighbors about ways in which we can protect nature. Tell your parents, celebrate Earth Day, or write letters to local or national leaders who make decisions that could affect nature.
Get educated
Get educated
<a href="https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/youth/">Learn more about the place you live</a> in and how to protect it. How clean is the river that runs through your town, for example? Are there people in your neighborhood who are already doing things to help protect the water and the people who use the river for work or play?
Learn more about the place you live in and how to protect it. How clean is the river that runs through your town, for example? Are there people in your neighborhood who are already doing things to help protect the water and the people who use the river for work or play?
This interactive experience was written by Torea Frey, based on reports and articles from McKinsey on conserving nature, as well as external research on the economic value of mangroves, with contributions from biodiversity experts Duko Hopman and Olivia Sanchez. It is brought to you by McKinsey Global Publishing, in a collaborative effort by Mike Borruso, Ryan Hatch, Drew Holzfeind, Richard Johnson, Stephen Landau, Janet Michaud, Kanika Punwani, Charmaine Rice, Dan Spector, and Nathan Wilson, with Justin Metz and Chris Philpot providing additional illustration support.
This is the third piece in our McKinsey for Kids series. Check out the two previous editions, which focused on fish farming and food waste.
If you have read this far, we hope you have enjoyed it. Want to tell us what you thought and how we could have made it even more enjoyable and useful to you? Drop a note to our publisher, Raju Narisetti, at newideas@mckinsey.com.